Seattle Seahawks fans have all seen the quarterback situation unfold this season. When Drew Lock plays, the team wins. When Sam Darnold plays, the team struggles. Is a QB1 change needed? Richard Sherman says not so fast.
On his eponymous podcast, while reacting to Week 10 games, Sherman brought up the problem with Lock seemingly outplaying Darnold while Darnold has missed time with various injuries. The Seahawks legend offered that Mike Macdonald has a decision to make, but that decision likely has already been made: Darnold will remain the starter when he is healthy again.
Sherman wisely broke down why: "(Drew Lock) has not been really challenged with great defenses yet. It's hard to compare what Sam Darnold does against a Denver Broncos...Then you watch Drew Lock against the Arizona Cardinals and the Raiders, and you go, 'Oh! He's better!' Not everything is created equal...Do we give Drew Lock a ton of credit? No question about it. But the circumstances are different."
Richard Sherman adds common sense to the Seattle Seahawks quarterback debate
Perfectly said, of course. While Lock has played interception-free football in his four games, the level of competition is far lower than what Darnold has faced. Lock has played the Arizona Cardinals twice, the New England Patriots in Week 1, beginning on the second drive, and the Las Vegas Raiders.
Arizona and New England are tied for 25th in terms of yards allowed per play (5.7), and the Raiders are last in the NFL (6.2). The Pats are 25th in quarterback rating allowed (100.4), while the Raiders are 30th (107.3) and the Cardinals are last (110.1). One could not ask for three easier defenses to play against than those three.
Darnold has played against the San Francisco 49ers (third in yards allowed per play (4.9) and the Denver Broncos (10th in YPP at 5.2 and eighth in quarterback rating allowed at 83.3), as well as the solid defenses of the Kansas City Chiefs and Chicago Bears, who had just traded for elite defensive lineman Jeffery Simmons.
As Sherman suggested, Darnold has taken on oranges, and Lock has faced moldy oranges. None of that means that Darnold is a far better player than Lock, of course, and maybe Lock is just in the midst of a hot streak, but which teams the quarterbacks have played against will obviously go into the decision of the Seahawks coaching staff on who should be QB1.
It would be rather shocking if Sam Darnold doesn't return as the starting quarterback when he is healthy enough to play again. He is dealing with a cracked rib and a quad injury. While Seattle has a bye week in Week 11, Darnold might not be ready to return by Week 12.
If Drew Lock plays after the bye week, the next game is against the 49ers. That would be Lock's first real test, and if he passes it with a great grade, a real quarterback controversy might emerge, and it should. The hope is that Seattle gets a victory in Week 12 no matter who is playing quarterback, of course.
