Studs and duds from Seattle Seahawks' frustrating first half of the season

The Seattle Seahawks kicked off the 2024 season with strong momentum, winning their first three games and igniting hope for a promising year. With a refreshed approach under new head coach Mike Macdonald, they looked poised to be serious contenders, blending a solid defense and a productive offense led by Geno Smith. Yet, as the season progressed, challenges began to surface, and the team's initial success quickly faded, leaving them in last place in the NFC West.

Despite the slide in standings, the Seahawks have still seen some impressive individual performances that stand out amid the struggles. Key players have stepped up in crucial moments, showcasing their talent and determination to keep the team competitive. At the same time, others have failed to meet expectations, struggling under the pressure and highlighting areas that have held the Seahawks back.

As they head into the second half of the season, Seattle is at a crossroads, needing to find a way to reclaim their early-season form. There is potential to turn things around, but it will require a renewed focus and consistency across the roster. The challenge now is to build on their strengths while addressing the weaknesses that have become apparent during their difficult stretch.

Two studs and two duds from the Seattle Seahawks' first half of the 2024 season

STUD - DK Metcalf

A key factor in the Seahawks’ strong start to the season was the outstanding play of star wide receiver DK Metcalf. With his unique blend of size, speed, and strength, Metcalf was a constant threat to defenses, racking up 568 receiving yards on 35 catches and scoring three touchdowns. His presence on the field provided Geno Smith with a reliable target, helping to set the tone for Seattle's early offensive success.

However, Metcalf’s impact became even clearer when he went down with a knee injury, sidelining him for two games. The void left by his absence was significant, as the Seahawks lost a major playmaker and offensive focal point. Without their top receiver, the team had to adjust quickly, and the responsibility fell on other wideouts to help fill the gap.

In Metcalf’s absence, wide receivers Tyler Lockett and Jaxon Smith-Njigba were called upon to shoulder a heavier load in the passing game. Both players stepped up to keep the offense moving, but the Seahawks’ offensive rhythm and explosiveness were visibly affected. While they managed to adapt, the team continues to feel the impact of Metcalf’s absence, highlighting just how essential he is to their success.

DUD - Seahawks head coach Mike Macdonald

In the offseason, the Seattle Seahawks made a bold move, parting ways with longtime head coach Pete Carroll and bringing in Mike Macdonald, a young defensive mastermind, to lead the team. The decision brought a wave of excitement to Seattle, with fans eager to see what Macdonald could accomplish. His tenure started off strong, as the Seahawks won their first three games, sparking widespread admiration for the rookie head coach’s early success and his ability to energize the team.

However, as the season progressed, the initial magic began to fade, and the Seahawks struggled to maintain their winning momentum. Macdonald’s in-game decision-making came under scrutiny as losses mounted, and his choices in key moments were questioned. It became evident that the transition to a new system—and a new leader—was not without challenges, revealing that there would be growing pains in his first year at the helm.

While some missteps are expected for a first-time head coach, certain mistakes underscored the steep learning curve Macdonald faces. Adjusting to the expectations and demands of this level, especially following a coach as experienced as Carroll, requires resilience and adaptability. For the Seahawks to thrive, Macdonald will need to address these rookie errors and continue developing his strategic approach as he settles into his new role.

STUD - Julian Love

In recent years, the Seattle Seahawks have faced persistent challenges on the defensive side of the ball. The departure of legendary linebacker Bobby Wagner left a significant void in leadership and playmaking ability, creating a pressing need for someone to step up and fill his shoes.

This season, linebacker Julian Love has risen to the occasion, making an impact that has been felt across the field. Love has been a tackling machine, racking up 47 tackles and adding two interceptions to his impressive stat line. His ability to make timely plays has provided a boost to Seattle’s defense, helping to mitigate the loss of Wagner and instilling some stability in a position that was previously a concern.

Love’s contributions have been invaluable, as his awareness and versatility bring a sense of reliability to the Seahawks' defense. While it’s a tall order to fully replace a player of Wagner’s caliber, Love’s performance has been a bright spot in an otherwise up-and-down season. His ability to step into this role has given Seattle hope for the future as they work to rebuild a formidable defensive unit.

DUD - Seahawks offensive Line

As the Seahawks’ losses continue to pile up, the blame has started circulating, and much of it has landed on quarterback Geno Smith. While it's natural for the quarterback to be a focal point of criticism, Smith isn’t the sole culprit behind Seattle’s offensive struggles. The offensive line has repeatedly failed to protect him, allowing defenders to get through with ease, which forces Smith to rush his throws—often leading to turnovers and missed opportunities.

The offensive line’s issues go beyond pass protection; they’ve also struggled to create openings for the running game. Kenneth Walker III and Zach Charbonnet have rarely had clear lanes to exploit, often encountering defenders almost immediately after receiving the handoff. Without adequate blocking, Seattle's talented running backs are limited to minimal gains, making it difficult for the team to establish any rhythm on the ground.

These combined struggles up front have placed a heavy burden on the entire offense, leaving both the passing and running games stifled. For the Seahawks to improve offensively, their line will need to step up and provide the stability and support that both Smith and the running backs desperately need. Until these issues are addressed, the offense will continue to be a source of frustration and missed potential.

The Seattle Seahawks must find a way to break out of their current slump before their season spirals beyond recovery. To do so, they’ll need a complete team effort, with improved performance across the board. Offensively, better protection for Geno Smith and stronger run-blocking from the offensive line is essential to give their playmakers a chance to shine. Defensively, they’ll need more consistency and fewer missed assignments if they want to effectively stop opponents and shift momentum in their favor.

Ultimately, if the Seahawks hope to turn their season around, each unit must rise to the challenge and address the weaknesses that have held them back. With the talent present on the roster, the potential for a turnaround exists—but it will take focus, discipline, and a renewed commitment from every player and coach.

More Seahawks news and analysis: