How Good (or Bad) is Charlie Whitehurst?

I’m not anything more than a fan of the Seattle Seahawks.

I don’t have professional coaching experience or access to heaps of reviewable film from games. I don’t attend Seahawks practices unless they’re open to the public; like any other fan, a majority of my Seahawks awareness is dependent on guys like Dave Boling, Danny O’Neil, or Clare Farnsworth.

But lately, a few reports from Seahawks camp have been contradictory: how good (or bad) is Charlie Whitehurst?

Earlier this week, Dave Boling posted an opinionated blurb that had even ESPN Insider double-checking their faith in Whitehurst:

At quarterback, Whitehurst had a pretty nice series in a two-minute session, but he threw two picks in the Red Zone, too. For my money, and I think I’ve seen every OTA session that has been open to us, I think JP Losman is far closer to being a game-ready productive quarterback than Whitehurst. Losman really has a big-time arm on him, and an awful lot of experience.

That opinion is quite depressing; I was more of an optimist than a critic when it came to the acquisition of Charlie Whitehurst.

But I suppose Losman should be more of a game-ready quarterback than Whitehurst. Losman has thirty-four career starts in the National Football League; Whitehurst has yet to throw a regular-season pass.

The Seahawks acquired Whitehurst with the hope that he could develop into a starting quarterback at some point beyond 2010. His experience holding a clipboard under the tutelage of Norv Turner may be beneficial for the future, but most certainly not for his initial OTA sessions in Seattle.

Whitehurst probably shouldn’t impress anyone right away – think Matt Hasselbeck in 2001 – but it would be somewhat disappointing if he wasn’t able to secure a spot on the depth chart ahead of J.P. Losman.

Thanks to patience and optimism, however, it appears as if Whitehurst has potential after all. Danny O’Neil wrote this about Whitehurst and the Seahawks’ offseason finale:

Charlie Whitehurst threw a high-arcing, perfectly placed deep ball that resulted in a few gasps but ultimately an incompletion after it glanced off the hands of Isaiah Stanback.

Not too worry, though. Whitehurst threw an equally good looking ball to Kole Heckendorf for a touchdown.

This final day of offseason work was as impressive as Whitehurst as I’ve seen him during the offseason workouts. He made a nice throw on the run that Deon Butler grabbed during seven-on-seven drills.

Without access to game film or practice sessions, homer optimism is all I’ve got for Charlie Whitehurst. Even with access, however, I’m not sure Whitehurst has enough work in the league to make an accurate judgment of his game.

The preseason and training camp can’t start soon enough.

Shaun Dolence: [email protected]
Follow 12th Man Rising

Next Seahawks Game View full schedule »
Thursday, Sep 44 Sep5:30Green Bay PackersBuy Tickets
Dick's Sporting Goods presents "Hell Week":

Tags: Charlie Whitehurst J.P. Losman Matt Hasselbeck Offseason OTA Practice Preseason Quarterback Seattle Seahawks Training Camp

  • Jrock

    I don’t know my gut tells me he is dog @#&%

    • Shaun Dolence

      I get the opposite feeling. There aren’t any real results we can use now to gauge the competence of the new administration, however, so we’ll have to wait and see.

      I remember having the same feeling about Hasselbeck, and that turned out okay. Then again, a young quarterback hand-picked and coached by Mike Holmgren is an entirely different story.

  • Rob

    Losman is your guy, he got tossed under the bus in Buffalo by a terrible coach for a guy (Edwards) who cannot play. Given a objective open competition in Buffalo he would beat out anyone currently on that roster, as he would in Oakland and Jacksonville.

    There is a reason Whitehurst has never thrown a regular season pass and its not just Rivers.

    • Shaun Dolence

      It’s good to hear a different, informed perspective on Losman. But if you remember, after Buffalo opted to go in a different direction, he spent the 2009 season with the Las Vegas Locomotives of the UFL.

      And he had his opportunity with Oakland; he was signed in December because of injuries, but was unable to retain a roster spot. He fell behind Bruce Gradkowski, Jamarcus Russell, and Charlie Frye.

      I’m not an NFL talent evaluator, but I’ve got to believe that if he is that good he would’ve found an opportunity — and playing time — before coming to Seattle.

  • redzone59

    It looks to me like Whitehurst is starting to feel more comfortable with this new offense. Playing rather then thinking about it first. I do think Losman might be second at the opening of the season but really thats not a bad thing. Losman would have made great things happen if he was drafted by another franchise. The Bills were stars go to die.
    I like Whitehurst I remember him in the senior bowl. He will be a great player one day. I just hope PC runs up the score so Whitehurst gets some playing time. It would be garbage time but any xp is better then non.

  • Jrock

    I can’t wait for pre season to see what these guys look like. i get this feeling that Losman will wind up starting a game this season and I think he’ll do better than Senaca. Something about him i like. I hope I’m wrong about Clippy Jesus. I would love for both Losman AND Whitehurst both look very promising and it’s a big question mark who gets the nod. Both certainly have potential